
Am I the only one who thinks of
Big Top Pee-Wee when I think of egg salad? I couldn't find a video of the scene but I will paraphrase it for you:
Pee-Wee's girlfriend, Winnie: "I made you your favorite!" (for lunch)
Pee-Wee guesses and guesses: "Ham and cheese? Tomato soup? Tunafish?" etc, etc.
Until finally Winnie has to say, "No... Egg salad."
Then Pee-Wee has to say, "Egg salad! My favorite!"
Which I guess is a joke because egg salad is nobody's favorite?
And while it may seem like a strange/overly simple thing to explain, I've heard many people say, "I'm a great cook but one thing I always mess up is a hard boiled egg." Kind of like my brother-in-law who is a chef but still always messes up rice. The simple things can trip you up, folks!
Anyway, I like egg salad now but I had to learn to like it by making it myself. Here's the only way I had ever had it before:
Take a hard boiled egg.
Mash it in a bowl with mayonnaise.
Maybe add salt, too.
Put it on bread but DON'T toast the bread.
The end.
Then I got inspired when I was working as a hostess at a busy, fancyish restaurant in New York City. Being a hostess was not as great as being a waitress because we got paid less. But! Being a hostess was also BETTER than being a waitress because a) we had to do less running around, b) we didn't have to wear the terrible uniform and instead got to wear our own clothes, just in black, and c) when it came time for our break we got to order our food instead of eating "family meal."
Family meal was, nine times out of ten, terrible. I mean... it would be something like BEANS. That's all. Whereas I, as a hostess, could eat yummy gruyere grilled cheese or beet salad or, sometimes, egg salad.
The egg salad at this restaurant was better than any egg salad I'd ever had for one main reason: they separated the whites from the yolks before mashing. This made it much less mushy and, in my opinion, much more delicious.
So, now that I've written way too much about something simple, here is my version of that slightly-fancier, hostess-inspired, just-in-time-to-use-up-your-Easter-eggs egg salad.
(Oh, and if you hate eggs or mayonnaise, just run along and come back another day. I promise I will make something much less mayonnaisey and eggy-
mayonneggy?- next time.)
You will need:
-eggs (I used six this time which made about 4-6 servings)
-mayo
-grainy mustard
-salt
-pepper
-dill
That's all! It's not hard.
-Start by covering your eggs with cold water and setting them over high heat:

-When the bubbles become pea sized (like a real pea, not like a frozen pea), remove the pot from the heat, cover, and set aside for exactly twelve minutes:
-Run the eggs under cold water:

-and peel- running them under the cold water makes this easier. (Sorry, I wear gloves when I cook because I have eczema on my hands. This is why you won't see my hands in many pictures.)

-separate the yolks from the whites!
-Dice the whites and set aside:
-Mash the yolks with a fork and add a couple plops of mayo (this is probably about a quarter cup), and a plop of seedy mustard (maybe a tablespoon):

-add salt and pepper to taste:

-Sprinkle dill all over the top and mix the whites back in:
-Eat it! I ate mine on toast with tomato and pea shoots. Added a little crunch to the mush.